By James Gort. Originally published on LinkedIn on May 8, 2026.
You did not get into public accounting to think about cybersecurity. You got into it to do good work for the clients who trust you with their most sensitive numbers. Most days, that is what you do. But there is a quiet question in the back of most CPA partners’ heads, especially when busy season slows down enough to leave room for it. Are we actually as buttoned up as we need to be?
Most firms I talk to are running at least two of the three workflow habits below. Not because anyone is careless, but because the rules quietly moved while everyone was working. The amended FTC Safeguards Rule, which expanded to cover tax preparers and accountants when it was rewritten in 2021, took full effect on June 9, 2023. Most of what changed lives inside the day-to-day workflow of the firm, not in a binder on a shelf. The good news is that the gaps are usually small. The work to close them is too.
This is not the article where I tell you the FTC is going to fine you into oblivion. They are not parked outside your office. The point is more practical. The Rule changed what normal is supposed to look like inside a CPA firm, and most firms have not caught up yet. Here is what I see most often and what good looks like instead.
1. You email returns as password-protected PDFs
The instinct is right. You don’t want to send a tax return as a plain attachment. The execution is where it tends to fall apart.
In most firms, the password to the PDF travels in the next email reply or in a phone call the staff member forgets to make. Even when a firm is disciplined about delivering the password through a separate channel, regular email is not a secure channel. The encryption that protects email in transit, called TLS, is opportunistic. It works when both mail servers support it and silently does not when they do not. The Safeguards Rule requires encryption of customer information in transit (16 CFR 314.4(c)(3)). A password-protected PDF moving over unreliable transport does not clear that bar, and the audit trail you would want in a worst-case scenario does not exist.
What good looks like is a real client portal, used for everything. TaxDome, SmartVault, Verifyle, Liscio, ShareFile, and Citrix Files are all options. Any of them is better than encrypted-PDF-by-email theater. Pick one. Train clients on it once. The first three weeks are awkward, and then it becomes the way your firm operates.
2. Multiple people share one login to the tax software
This is the most common habit and the most expensive one to keep.
Two associates working under the same Lacerte login. Three preparers passing one MFA token around at the start of the morning. One UltraTax credential, four people, busy season. It saves the firm a few thousand dollars in license fees. It also breaks three Safeguards requirements at the same time. Multi-factor authentication for each individual user (314.4(c)(5)). Access controls based on least privilege (314.4(c)(1)). The ability to know who accessed what data and when (314.4(c)(8)). IRS Publication 4557, which has applied to tax preparers for years, also requires unique user credentials and prohibits sharing.
What good looks like is every staff member who touches client data having their own login, their own MFA, and access only to the clients and functions they need. Yes, that costs more in licenses. The math against the cost of a single breach investigation is not close.
3. Clients text documents to staff phones
This one feels the most innocent. It is technically the messiest.
A client doesn’t want to log into a portal. They text a W-2 to the bookkeeper’s cell because that is how they always have. The image lands on the bookkeeper’s personal phone, syncs to her personal iCloud or Google Photos, sits there indefinitely, gets backed up to a service the firm has no agreement with, and travels with that backup if she ever loses or replaces the phone.
Three Safeguards problems compound here. SMS and MMS are not encrypted in a way the Rule recognizes (314.4(c)(3) on encryption in transit). The firm has no inventory of where its client data lives (314.4(c)(1) on knowing the systems holding customer information). And by default, the firm has made Apple or Google a service provider holding regulated client data without any of the oversight the Rule expects (314.4(f)).
What good looks like is a secure intake method that clients are told about up front and staff who are trained never to accept sensitive documents through SMS or personal email. The portal that fixes the first problem fixes this one too.
What "good" actually feels like inside the firm
None of these three habits are exotic. They are the quiet ways a 2018 firm became a 2026 firm without realizing the Rule moved underneath it. Closing the gaps is rarely about buying expensive new technology. It is about being deliberate with the tools and licenses you already pay for and about deciding that the small friction of doing things correctly costs less than the alternative of finding out the hard way.
The firms that have done this work are not more paranoid than yours. They sleep a little better during busy season. When a client asks how their data is protected, the answer is short and confident. When the cyber insurance renewal questionnaire shows up, it is twenty minutes of work instead of a week of scrambling. When something goes wrong somewhere else in the world, the partners read the news without that small private flinch of "that could that have been us!"
That is the real outcome. Not a perfect firm. A firm that has caught up to what the Rule expects, and that is one less thing in the back of the partner’s head.
A few honest caveats. The FTC Safeguards Rule has more requirements than these three habits touch. Written information security program, designated qualified individual, risk assessment, written incident response plan, vendor management, periodic testing, annual reporting to the governing body. A firm that fixes email, logins, and texting still has work to do. And the Rule sits underneath a stack of other obligations. IRS Publication 4557, state notification laws, and your malpractice carrier’s expectations. Those are yours to navigate with your attorney. We help firms build and operate the technical controls. The legal and regulatory interpretation belongs with your counsel.
If you recognized your own firm in one or more of these, you are in good company. As I mentioned earlier, most of the firms I talk to on a first call are running at least two of them. The way forward is not dramatic. It is a portal, real licensing discipline, and a short conversation with your team about what gets accepted through what channel. A few weeks of friction, and then it is just how the firm runs.
Before filing season, check the evidence behind your WISP and download the worksheet.